Mysterious Disappearances anime

Anime Like Mysteries, Maidens, And Mysterious Disappearances

Sumireko Ogawa is a bookstore clerk who, despite celebrating some literary success in high school, has been unable to produce any more quality writing in her 20s. However, after she gets caught up in a string of mysterious events happening in the city, she gained the ability to transform into a child, which has finally spurred her creativity.

Helped by her flirty young co-worker, Ren Adashino, with her mysterious condition, she starts to help him investigate the other mysterious occurrences happening in the city. However, Ren has a mysterious secret of his own.

Everyone will remember this for the ridiculous booba and not its mysteries. If you are looking for more anime recommendations like Mysteries, Maidens, And Mysterious Disappearances, head on down below.

Anime Like Mysteries, Maidens, And Mysterious Disappearances

For Fans of Investigating The Supernatural

dark gathering anime

Dark Gathering

Keitarou Gentouga is a college student who hates ghosts. Unfortunately, spirits have always been unnaturally attracted to him, so much so that he was previously a shut-in after causing his childhood friend, Eiko Houzuki, and himself to get cursed by a spirit.

However, Eiko helped him get back out into the world, and as part of his rehabilitation, he started tutoring Eiko’s young cousin, Yayoi.

It isn’t long before Keitarou finds that Yayoi actively seeks out dangerous spirits, using him and various other tools to capture them for a mysterious purpose that all stems back to the spirit that took Yayoi’s mother after her death.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Dark Gathering

  • Older characters hanging out with younger characters and investigating supernatural
  • Both address a lot of urban legend-type mysteries
  • Just a bit of nice slice of life in between the much darker horror
  • Unexpected lewd moments/references – unexpected because they are both horror anime.

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Dark Gathering

  • Dark Gathering is specifically ghost hunting while Mysterious Disappearances is more mysterious about what is going on.
  • Dark Gathering is actually a bit horrific and creepy in a lot of its supernatural, which is a rarity among all horror anime.
bakemonogatari-anime

Bakemonogatari

After surviving a vampire attack, high school student Koyomi Araragi finds he has several supernatural side effects that remained after being cured including the ability to rapidly heal.

While trying to live a normal life after the event, he ends up catching a classmate, Hitagi Senjougahara, as she fell down some stairs. As he catches her, he discovers that she is near weightless after being inflicted with a curse.

After enlisting the help of the easy-going wandering Shinto priest that helped him with his vampirism, Araragi finds himself embroiled in not just Senjogahara’s issue but several different supernatural events afflicting those in his town.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Bakemonogatari

  • Supernatural boys with secret abilities helping a bunch of women afflicted with supernatural maladies.
  • Off-handed remarks about the beautiful women they are helping/working with
  • Legitimately interesting supernatural maladies with an above average amount of thought put into crafting them.
  • Horrific moments, occasionally lewd moments
  • Both series enjoy their long moments of dialogue

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Bakemonogatari

  • Bakemonogatari is a harem rom-com anime hidden under a mountain of clever dialogue and world building. Mysterious Disappearances is a more straightforward supernatural mystery anime.
  • Bakemonogatari gets a bit “surreal and artistic” at times.
toilet bound hanako anime

Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun

Hanako is said to be a ghost that occupies the third stall of the third floor girls’ bathroom in the old building. When summoned, she is said to grant any wish.

Nene, an occult lover with dreams of romance, summons Hanako, only to find out that this traditionally girl ghost is a boy!

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun

  • Both follow a supernatural boy and the human girls that get tangled up in helping them
  • The boys are mysterious, occasionally bordering on sinister
  • Both series feature episodic urban legend-like mysteries all building towards an overall mystery
  • The overall mystery of each series is about the male lead
  • The mysteries are both surprisingly dark and well thought out.

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun

  • You know how Sumireko has that just ridiculously huge chest? Well, the characters in Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun are the anti-Sumireko. Stylized moe flatness for all.
  • Toilet-bound Hanako-kun is about school children and limits the mysteries to those within the school.
dr ramune anime

Dr. Ramune – Mysterious Diseases Specialist

If something takes root deep enough in someone’s heart, it can attract spirits that will cause mysterious diseases that modern medicine cannot cure.

For those that have these unique ailments, like crying condiments from your eyes, there is Dr. Ramune who helps his patients explore the root cause of the issue in order to rid them of the disease.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Dr. Ramune

  • Both series follow a guy capable of solving supernatural problems and his helpful assistant
  • The supernatural problems are occasionally a little comical, but mostly dark/sad.

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Dr. Ramune

  • Dr. Ramune solves supernatural ailments that all manifest as some sort of weird food-related disease like soy sauce tears, gyoza ears, ect. So it is bit silly in that respect, but they actually make it just as sinister as Mysterious Disappearances.
  • Dr. Ramune has a whole lot more men, and zero large Sumireko-sized chests.

For Fans of Urban Mysteries

occultic nine anime

Occultic;Nine

Brought together by a blog disproving the supernatural, nine unique individuals are confronted with both murder and the supernatural when they try to solve the mysteries within the city and get caught up in the events.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Occultic;Nine

  • Supernatural mysteries set in a dark contemporary urban setting
  • Urban legend-style supernatural mysteries
  • Gritty, dark stories with the occasional moment of gore
  • Both series enjoy keeping things vague as well as menacing

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Occultic;Nine

  • Occultic;Nine is investigating a larger mystery through a series of smaller related ones. Occultic;Nine also does explores its mystery through a larger cast of characters that are more fleshed out.
inspectre anime

In/Spectre

At a young age, Kotoko Iwanaga was abducted by yokai and asked to become their Goddess of Wisdom to act as a mediator between spiritual and human issues. She agreed and lost her right eye and left leg in the agreement.

Meanwhile, Kotoko meets Kuro Sakuragawa, a man who just broke up with his girlfriend after a kappa fled before him.

Kotoko makes her move to not only lock him down as a boyfriend, but to have him help her settle various disputes with spirits.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and In/Spectre

  • Both series are supernatural mystery solvers, but in a contemporary urban setting
  • A male and female duo deal with a handful of different cases.
  • Urban legend-style supernatural mysteries
  • Romantic chemistry? Baiting? Whatever you call it, both have it.

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and In/Spectre

  • In/Spectre follows a mediator for yokai who have conflicts with the human world and/or are causing trouble.
  • While both series offer up interestingly detailed cases, the causes in Mysterious Disappearances are usually darker and often more gruesome.
blast of tempest anime main characters

Blast of Tempest

Hakaze Kusaribe is a sorceress tasked with protecting the Tree of Origins. However, when a rival member of her family seeking to revive the Tree of World’s End catches her, she is stuffed into a barrel and banished to an island.

From there, Hakaze sends a message out to sea, one received by Mahiro Fuwa. In agreement to help Hakaze off the island, he asks that she use her magic to help find his sister’s killer.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Blast of Tempest

  • Both could be called “contemporary urban fantasy” anime, blending magic/supernatural with an urban setting.
  • There is a building story unfolding in the city that the main characters end up caught up in
  • The male main character becomes increasingly close to a girl that is helping him
  • The male lead has their own mystery that is slowly being fed to you over the course of the series.

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Blast of Tempest

  • Blast of Tempest is more fantasy magic action mystery than supernatural mystery
  • Blast of Tempest has more obvious romantic elements
  • The mystery in Blast of Tempest is a singular linear one, not an episodic building one like in Mysterious Disappearances.
call of the night anime

Call of the Night

After rejecting a confession from a girl at school because he doesn’t understand love, Kou stops going to school and starts wandering the night with insomnia.

One night, he encounters a mysterious girl who believes people that stay awake at night are dissatisfied with the way they spent their days.

Following her into the night, she brings him back to her place and suddenly starts to suck his blood. Discovering her true nature, Kou now seeks to be a vampire, but to become one, you need to make a vampire fall in love with you.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Call of the Night

  • Normal looking cities with a lot of supernatural beings just wandering around living lives
  • Occasional very sinister air to even the main characters
  • Both wax philosophical about love or aging.

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Call of the Night

  • Call of the Night is more a romance than a mystery
  • Call of the Night lacks the same depth to its supernatural story that Mysterious Disappearances has
durarara anime

Durarara

Tokyo’s downtown district of Ikebukuro is awash in strange rumors, everything from colorless color gangs to a headless rider roaming town populate the rumors.

For Mikado Ryuugamine who just moved there from the countryside, he is but one witness to the district’s slew of strange events.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Durarara

  • Normal city setting, but supernatural stories are happening frequently within
  • Multiple different character stories
  • Urban legend-style mysteries that are not immediately easily solved

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Durarara

  • Durarara has multiple individual character stories happening concurrently that are all weaving together. It is interesting to see how they all become related, but Mysterious Disappearances, by comparison, is just episodic mysteries.
  • There is no very obvious main character in Dururua like there is in Mysterious Disappearances.

For Fans of Horror, but a Little Lewd Sometimes

mieruko anime

Mieruko-chan

Miko is a normal high school girl who has found her life turned upside down by the sudden ability to see spirits.

Despite being terrified by what she sees, she does her best to not acknowledge the spirits so they leave her alone.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Mieruko-chan

  • The supernatural exists unseen all over, apparently
  • Not ecchi, but definitely has a lingering gaze and/or off-handed ecchi remarks.
  • Occasionally horrifying and creepy, but sometimes just slice of life

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Mieruko-chan

  • Mieruko is about a girl that can see legitimately horrifying ghosts, but pretends she can’t while also trying to keep people safe from the actions of those ghosts.
  • Mieruko is solely about high school girls, not the gamut of ages that you see in Mysterious Disappearances.
  • While both are supernatural, Mieruko isn’t really any sort of a “mystery” anime like Mysterious Disappearances is.
dusk maiden of amnesia anime

Dusk Maiden of Amnesia

For 60 years, the Seikyou Private Academy has been haunted by a ghost known as Yuuko, a young woman that died in the basement.

With no memory of her life, the ghost founds the Paranormal Investigation Club to find answers.

Similarities Between Mysterious Disappearances and Dusk Maiden of Amnesia

  • Supernatural mystery anime
  • Both series explore the building relationship between a smaller boy and an older woman
  • A solid mix of slice of life with actual sinister supernatural moments.

Differences Between Mysterious Disappearances and Dusk Maiden of Amnesia

  • As a ghost is a major character, Dusk Maiden of Amnesia keeps its mysteries bound to the school she is bound to.
  • Dusk Maiden of Amnesia is also a romance anime.
  • The mysteries in Dusk Maiden of Amnesia are more standard ghost stories and are not quite as intricate and creative as Mysterious Disappearances.

Do you have more anime recommendations like Mysteries, Maidens, And Mysterious Disappearances? Let fans know in the comments section below.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top